Arena Stage’s Sensational Revisal of Damn Yankees Hits It Out of the Park
Damn Yankees
Arena Stage
Jordan Wright
September 21, 2025
Ana Villafañe (Lola) and Jordan Donica (Joe Hardy) in Damn Yankees at Arena Stage. (Photo/Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman)
Call it a “revisal” as Artistic Director Hana S. Sharif did on opening night or call it a revival which those familiar with the 1955 musical might say. Whatever term of art you choose, I recommend getting off the bench now, because there was a ‘producers’ performance’ last week and there is a hot chance it will go to Broadway, so you can say you saw it here first.
Remember Dear Evan Hansen? It started its B’way journey at Arena Stage. So did groundbreaking shows such as The Great White Hope, Sweat, Next to Normal, Looped and A Night with Janis Joplin. Celebrating its 75th Anniversary Season, Arena has always been a nexus for groundbreaking theatrical exploration.
So, why revive Damn Yankees? It’s simple. Do not doubt the power of a story about baseball, the devil, a sexy siren with a conscience, a loving wife and a desire to be more than your past all underpinned by a brilliant score. This fresh reimagining brings heavy hitters to the stage. Will Power and Douglas Wallop collaborated on the adaptation and Lynn Ahrens brightened original composers Richard Adler’s and Jerry Ross’ music and lyrics with modernized lyrics and slips in a few snappy zingers to reflect our fraught political times. Not only does this iteration have an exceptional cast (more on that later) but its staging dazzles in every way. From special effects and lighting to video projections, clever illusions and choreography, it absolutely slays.
One of the script tweaks here is in the original production the team was the Washington Senators. They’re now the Baltimore Orioles. Look for the “Oriole Bird” who makes a brief onstage appearance to pump up the audience. As Applegate wisecracks, “Baltimore is like Newark, but with crabs.”
There are plenty of sports franchises who regard athletes’ agents as the devil incarnate. Here the devil is Applegate, – a con artist, evil grifter and all-around hustler who convinces our hero, Joe Boyd, to sell his aging body and leave his wife to become a star slugger with the Orioles. “And that’s why it’s called the art of the deal,” Applegate tells Joe. Joe’s dad had suffered racism in professional baseball when Black players could only play in the Negro leagues until Jackie Robinson broke the color barrier to play for the NY Giants in 1955. Joe is determined to right this wrong and avenge his father’s limited career. His impulse becomes a powerful motive for his decision to sell his soul to Applegate.
Rob McClure (Applegate). (Photo/Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman)
To convince Joe, Applegate enlists his wily partner Lola, who is as convincing as a henchman with a shiv and as alluring as whipped cream on a banana split. As Lola sings in the tango number when she seduces Joe, “Whatever Lola Wants”, she gets.
Applegate is played wicked slick by Broadway veteran Rob McClure known for roles in Mrs. Doubtfire and Beetlejuice. The diverse cast includes a hunky-hot chorus of ballplayer dancers delivering extra sizzle and swing alongside the notorious siren, Lola, played by luscious Broadway star Ana Villafañe known for her award-winning roles of Gloria in B’way’s On Your Feet and Roxie in Chicago. Young Joe Hardy is played by the extraordinary Jordan Donica a baritenor with superb range and movie star looks who will steal your heart if you let him. I did. Quentin Earl Darrington shines as the elderly Joe Boyd on the crux of a life-changing decision in a perfect counterpoint casting to his adoring wife Meg, played by the superb honey-voiced actress, Bryonha Marie, whose impressive bio is as long as your arm.
Highly recommended!!! With 25 memorable numbers, a full orchestra and an historic nine Tony Awards for the original, this splashy new production hits it out of the park!
Alysha Umphress (Gloria Thorpe) and the company of Damn Yankees. (Photo/Matthew Murphy and Evan Zimmerman)
With Alysha Umphress as Gloria Thorpe; Giuseppe Bausilio as Fuzzy/Ensemble; Raúl Contreras as Peña/Ensemble; Deanna Cudjoe, Ensemble; John Michael Fiumara as Gonzalez/Ensemble; Rayanne Gonzales as Sister/Ensemble; Danielle Marie Gonzalez, Ensemble; Michael Harmon as Smokey/Ensemble; Nehal Joshi as Ito/Ensemble; Ryo Kamibayashi as Ito/Ensemble; Georgia Monroe, Ensemble; Keenan McCarter as Welch; Kevin Munhall as Commissioner/Ensemble; J Savage as Sohovik/Ensemble; Justin Showell as Rocky/Ensemble; Sarah Anne Sillers as Doris/Ensemble; Jordyn Taylor, Ensemble.
Brilliantly directed and choreographed by world renowned creative, Sergio Trujillo; Music Supervision and Arrangements by Greg Anthony Rassen; Set Design by Robert Brill; Costume Design perfection by Linda Cho; Lighting Design by Philip S. Rosenberg; Sound Design by Walter Trarbach; Score Supervisor, David Chase; Projection Design by Peter Nigrini; Wig & Hair Design by Charles G. LaPointe; Illusion Design by Paul Kieve.
Through November 9th at Arena Stage, 1101 Sixth Street, SW, Washington, DC 20024. For tickets and information call the box office at 202.554.9066 or visit www.ArenaStage.org.